What does Genesis chapter 44 mean?
The last chapter seemed to be a happy ending. Eleven of Jacob's sons are on their way back to Canaan with everything they came for. They have the grain they need to avoid starvation. They have Simeon, released from prison after being held as security. And they have Jacob's beloved Benjamin, safe and well. They even have their money, once again returned, seemingly with their knowledge, adding yet another blessing. They have not yet realized that the powerful Egyptian governor with whom they've dealt is their estranged brother, Joseph (Genesis 42:7–8), who is testing them (Genesis 44:1–2).Joseph's test continues by having his own personal, valuable silver cup hidden in the grain sack carried by Benjamin. Under Joseph's orders, the steward catches up with the brothers on the road back to Canaan. He questions them harshly, accusing them of stealing the cup. Naturally, the brothers protest loudly. They have no idea the cup is with them. Seeking to prove their innocence, they make a foolish offer: if any of them are found with the cup, that man will be killed, and the rest will become slaves to the ruler (Genesis 44:3–10).
The steward pounces on the offer, while changing it. He insists, as Joseph has instructed him, that the man found with the cup will become a slave and the rest will be free to go. The brothers all quickly open their sacks to be searched in order from oldest to youngest. The steward, who put the cup in Benjamin's sack, makes a show of searching all the others before finding it there. This results in a display of intense grief and frustration—but the brothers do not leave. They return to the city along with Benjamin and the steward (Genesis 44:11–13).
The Egyptian ruler—still unrecognized as Joseph—insists that the men can go free if Benjamin remains behind as a slave. This is a direct parallel to the situation Joseph faced when his brothers—these same men, other than Benjamin—sold him as a slave some twenty years ago (Genesis 37:24–28). In that moment, the ten oldest sons of Jacob cruelly and jealously left an innocent person in slavery, grieving their father, to serve their own interests. Now, with Benjamin, they face a similar choice. Will they leave an innocent one and once again trouble their father (Genesis 44:14–17).
Fortunately for them all, Judah speaks on behalf of the family. He confesses his guilt, though he knows Benjamin and the rest are innocent of stealing the cup. He knows, however, that he has guilt to bear for what he did to Joseph many years prior (Genesis 42:21–23). He passionately describes how their elderly father will die of grief if he loses his beloved youngest son. Judah tells how he pledged himself as safety for the boy. He could not bear to look into the eyes of his father and deliver the news that Benjamin had been left behind (Genesis 44:18–32).
This plea climaxes with a dramatic offer. Hoping Joseph's heart has been softened, Judah offers to take Benjamin's place as a slave. In this way, he will be able to save both the boy and Jacob. The same brother who masterminded a younger brother's sale into slavery (Genesis 37:26–27) is now begging to be kept as a slave to save a younger brother (Genesis 44:33–34).
Joseph has now seen his estranged brothers (Genesis 42:1–8), heard them admit guilt (Genesis 42:21–23), and been reunited with his younger brother (Genesis 43:29–30). Now, in response to a test, he hears Judah offer his own life in sacrifice. This finally breaks Joseph's controlled disguise. He will break down, clear the room of all Egyptians, and reveal his identity with great emotion (Genesis 45:1–3).